17
Jul
09

making criticism my friend

When’s the last time someone criticised you? If it’s quite long ago, most prob you haven’t been heading somewhere in life. But if you strive to break into new growth points, you will undoubtedly face criticism.

I used to think that criticism was such a rude, uninvited guest. There I was, feeling good about the meeting/event/lesson I just did, when someone would come up to me and say, “It just didn’t take off, did it? That was too unfocused/cliché/boring/etc.”

Talk about getting deflated faster than I could say ouch.

As a normal human being, I prefer to be praised than to be criticised, to be given affirmation rather than improvement points. (If you don’t identify with this, you should stop reading and get a shrink).

But I’ve also realised one truth: Commendation might tell me how I’ve grown from yesterday to today, but it tells me nothing about how I can grow from today to tomorrow. For the latter, I need criticism.

So how do I make this bad-mannered fellow my best buddy in the world?

Few steps that have helped me so far:

* See beyond the person’s negative facial expression, choice of words or tone. (At times, I feel slightly better if I prop up Clooney’s face over the critic’s in my mind. Or imagine John Mayer singing his feedback to me.)

* Find the kernel of truth, even if it’s real tiny. Then take it like how you’d eat a fish – swallow the good stuff; throw away the bones. Be objective, even if the other party is not fully so.

* Get them to reconstruct, not just deconstruct. E.g. “So, what would you have done specifically instead?” (If they can’t answer, I’d smile and walk away before I say something nasty.)

* Ask them back, “Since you have many ideas, are you keen to help us make the next meeting/event/lesson successful?” If they say yes, you’ve just roped in passionate free labour!

* If you’re not in the right frame of mind (e.g. too tired/discouraged/raw), thank the person then shelve it first. Go home, have a good sleep and reconsider the criticism the next day when you are refreshed.

* Proactively ask for criticism – from a group of trusted and capable people. There are only a few phone numbers I remember by heart; these are the people I’d call and ask, “How does this sound…” Better be stupid in front of few than many.

* Last but not least, laugh at yourself. A lot. You’re bound to make a gazillion mistakes in your life anyways. Yet the Kingdom will keep moving forward. And so should you.

So far, these are the steps I’ve taken to keep my life sane and my ministry fruitful. If you disagree, feel free to criticise this post. If you have other steps to add, do share your wisdom by clicking here.


3 Responses to “making criticism my friend”


  1. July 18, 2009 at 9:53 am

    Criticism is our dear friend but we don’t move in with it. Take the lesson and move somewhere else.

  2. 2 2wentys0mething
    July 18, 2009 at 11:08 am

    1) Ask for specific incidents. Don’t accept “you are ALWAYS like this/that”; “you NEVER did this/that”. Not so much as to stump the critic, rather, so that you know clearly where you may have erred.

    Do agree with the part about laughing at ourselves though. It takes away much of the tension, and since we are going to be making a host of other mistakes, might as well learn how to laugh at our silliness.

    oh yeah, just remember not to do it in front of the critic.

  3. 3 Weilingemia
    July 26, 2009 at 11:19 pm

    Awesome~~~ I love this post! U ARE RIGHT! *Claps* I haven’t hear you preach for probably a lifetime of a pig…(unless it looks too delicious…) If I ever get the chance and have anything to say, I’ll tell ya! Please return the favor! *Gently* :) ))


Leave a Reply




Random Thoughts

  • ended my fave day of the week with a most delicious time with roy and @Shuz24. roy, i wanna be your friend! hahahahaa! 3 hours ago
  • mugging at starbucks with @sexydebster and @ChantelTeo. need caffè mocha to perk me up. 1 day ago
  • Wow, MRT emergency brake on my way to novena. For a moment, i thought bruce willis was gonna pop up to tell us we're held hostage till Sun. 1 day ago
  • i have a love/hate relationship with friday. nevertheless, just gotta do what i've gotta do. and look forward to saturday night, baby! 1 day ago
  • one bad thing about a trip overseas is how much work piles up by the time one comes back. i'm snowed under! 2 days ago
  • Luggage in one hand. Baileys in the other. Wondering whassup with all the christmas decor at changi. I'm back! Craving for salted veg soup. 3 days ago
  • Explorin Bali alone while waitin for church staff to arrive. Now stretchin my legs at cafe while reading Hole in e Gospel. Breezy.. Sleepy.. 5 days ago
  • Went to an indo svc today. It was sedated til the choir sang a song in Latin. WOW! Wanted to clap but apparently it's not the practice here. 5 days ago

Blog Stats

  • 87,205 hits

Archives